Close X

DUI Blog

Anonymous 911 Call Satisfies Probable Cause For Police Intrusion

Posted by Kevin Trombold DUI Defense Attorney | May 13, 2014 | 0 Comments

Privacy_and_rights_of_citizens_at_risk?
Anonymous Tips and Police Interference
The Fourth Amendment provides protection for Americans against unreasonable searches and seizures of their property.   One foundational principle of the Fourth Amendment is known as "probable cause," which means that law enforcement agents must have a compelling reason to conduct a search. But in many cases, that "reason" to search a vehicle can be flimsier than the plastic of a driver's license.

This point was illustrated recently in a U.S. Supreme Court decision that was issued last month. The case involved a pickup truck that was pulled over by police by the California Highway Patrol. Troopers initiated the stop based on an anonymous 911 call which claimed that a truck matching the vehicle's description tried to run the caller off the road.   The troopers had no independent verification that the truck did anything wrong except the word from the anonymous 911 caller.

When the troopers approached the truck, they detected a smell of marijuana; and then discovered 30 pounds of pot following a search of the vehicle.  The two suspects filed a motion to have the evidence suppressed on the grounds that it was obtained from an illegal search. Once their motion was denied, a guilty finding was entered for the crime of transporting marijuana.

A California Court of Appeal affirmed the ruling, and the case was later appealed all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court.  In its ruling in Prado Navarette et al. v. California, the high court stated that although an anonymous tip by itself does not always constitute probably cause, the description of the suspected offending vehicle and its behavior was enough to warrant a traffic stop, especially since such driving behavior could be an indicator of DUI. The court also noted that it was reasonable to assume that the tip was valid based on the timeliness of the call in relation to the incident. As a result, the Supreme Court affirmed the lower courts' rulings.  This case stands for the the idea that 911 callers are "reliable."

It seems that the "probable cause" bar is getting lower and lower each year. Let us hope that this decision does not spur a wave of "anonymous" 911 calls to authorities in an effort to circumvent probable cause.

About the Author

Kevin Trombold DUI Defense Attorney

Highly rated by former clients, who praise his warm, knowledgeable courtside manner and his fierce determination to reduce or eliminate charges. An accomplished speaker, author, and leader in DUI defense statewide Kevin is well respected by judges, prosecutors, and other attorneys across the State of Washington for his expertise, integrity, and knowledge in the complicated forensic science area of impaired driving allegations.

Comments

There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

We Want To Hear From You


Your story matters. We want to hear from you. Call 206-971-0067 for a free consultation

Hundreds of Thrilled Clients


While my traffic case was minor, I didn't want to go it alone. My friend recommended Kevin to me. From the first phone conversation til it was resolved, Kevin and his team were pure perfection! This is the team you want on your side. Period. - K.M.