Close X

DUI Blog

DUI Breath Test Refusal Statutes Being Whittled Away

Posted by Kevin Trombold DUI Defense Attorney | Oct 07, 2013 | 0 Comments

Drinking_and_driving_laws_and_politics
Washington State DUI Evidence Rulings
States are constantly coming up with ways to address what is perceived as an explosion in the number of drunk drivers (even though statistics don't back up that assertion). One of the laws passed in recent years in many states pertains to consequences surrounding suspects' refusal of the Breath test. In many places, refusing to submit to such a test automatically exposes you to penalties which may include suspension of your driver's license or even criminal charges.

But several legal cases are starting to erode these types of statutes. One of them known as Missouri v. McNeely addressed whether a driver could be compelled to have his or her blood drawn to check for DUI. In this case, law enforcement had claimed that metabolization of alcohol in the blood constituted "exigent circumstances" which permits a nonconsensual blood draw. The court ruled against the prosecution, citing this practice as unconstitutional.Another case here in Washington pertained to an individual's presumption of guilt when refusing a breath test.

In State v. Gauthier, the court ruled that the mere fact that a person refused a DNA test did not indicate evidence of guilt, and thereby could not be used in a subsequent trial.  Numerous judges in Washington have begun suppressing "refusal evidence."

Even other states are following this new constitutional analysis. The most recent pertinent case occurred in Kansas, which passed a law criminalizing the refusal to take a Breathalyzer test for those who have been previously arrested and/or convicted of DUI offenses. A Wichita TV station reports that a Sedgwick County District Court judge ruled that this law violates the Fourth Amendment that prohibits illegal search and seizure. The judge ruled that a person exercising his or her constitutional rights should not be punished by the law for doing so. It's hard to predict whether these "refusal" laws will go away completely. But right now, the trend seems to be turning against the enforcement of such provisions.

About the Author

Kevin Trombold DUI Defense Attorney

Highly rated by former clients, who praise his warm, knowledgeable courtside manner and his fierce determination to reduce or eliminate charges. An accomplished speaker, author, and leader in DUI defense statewide Kevin is well respected by judges, prosecutors, and other attorneys across the State of Washington for his expertise, integrity, and knowledge in the complicated forensic science area of impaired driving allegations.

Comments

There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

We Want To Hear From You


Your story matters. We want to hear from you. Call 206-971-0067 for a free consultation

Hundreds of Thrilled Clients


While my traffic case was minor, I didn't want to go it alone. My friend recommended Kevin to me. From the first phone conversation til it was resolved, Kevin and his team were pure perfection! This is the team you want on your side. Period. - K.M.